Mightier Acorns

Journeys through Genealogy and Family History

A parody of a family coat of arms designed with acorns as elements, with the motto "ex gladnis potentioribus" Latin for "from Mighty Acorns"
From Mighty Acorns
  • Intrusive Thoughts

    For my regular readers, I owe you an explanation.

    Ten years ago, what happened in America in November 2016 was a hammer blow to me and my family. Two years ago, another followed. You know what I am referring to.

    In 2016, I was about a year into the first round of research on what would become The Callin Family History, and that project was a welcome anchor for my mind. From my point of view, a Russian intelligence operation had apparently successfully installed their preferred candidate in the White House, and all I could do about it was keep showing up for work and take care of my family. Throwing myself into the structure and remoteness of a major family history project helped me cope with the feelings of panic and anger that accompanied nearly every day of that first administration.

    The 2018 and 2020 Elections brought some relief, but it was pretty clear that Americans didn’t realize the danger wasn’t over, and 2024 proved that we had not done enough to put a stop to the erosion of our democracy. When I published The Callin Family History in 2022, I intended to move on to a new project: writing the long-delayed science fiction novel I conceived of in 2015.

    But making creative choices for my novel meant predicting a future that I wasn’t sure would ever come about. Every time I sat down and tried to write, I was overwhelmed with intrusive thoughts that made it impossible to work on the piece of art that I had in my head. Mightier Acorns owes much of its existence to the fact that doing genealogical research and writing about family history was an antidote to those bitter, intrusive, and ugly thoughts.

    It also (mostly) kept me from arguing pointlessly with strangers on the Internet.

    A week ago, something happened in American politics that I didn’t think was possible…or at least wasn’t likely. Americans turned out in record numbers and used their ballots to send an unmistakable message to our elected government that most of us are fed up with the open corruption, lack of basic human decency, and mocking cruelty that has taken over our government.

    The work of making America a place where human dignity and justice are part of our core values again is not done. We have a long way to go before that famous Arc of History starts to bend, but the overwhelming victory over the cynical bastards who have been profiting off of misery and injustice last Tuesday felt like a physical weight was lifted off of me.

    When that weight disappeared, I found my mind brimming with ideas. After a decade of not being able to think about a fictional world without being overwhelmed by the dark fears and anger that the real world forced on me, I couldn’t turn off the optimistic joy of exploring that fictional world.

    If you noticed that I missed my regular deadlines, I apologize. I hadn’t planned on this sudden pivot, and I fully intend to come back to writing the family history blog, but I don’t yet know how long this creative energy will last, or where it will take me.

    For now, I’m going to pause my Mightier Acorns schedule and focus on outlining and drafting my novel. I know this much: it is set in a near-future colony of Venus, on floating habitats at the surprisingly comfortable altitude of 50 kilometers (25-ish miles) above the planet’s surface. It will explore the nature of absolute vs. relative morality, and it will challenge our assumptions about settling a new world where land is literally not a factor. And

    The title will be Airborne.

    If you have questions or just want to check in, I’ll still be checking my email – your best bet is to use the Contact Me button.

  • Ahnentafel #36: Abraham Howard Witter (1859-1918)

    My 2nd-great-grandfather, Abraham Howard Witter (1859-1918), was born in Pennsylvania, but his family settled in Pottawatomie County, Kansas, when he was a boy. Abe married Nancy Ellen “Ella” Shriver on 11 Feb 1885, and they lived in Belvue Township, raising seven children in Wamego and in St Marys.

    1892: A Microblog

    I used to teach a class on social media collaboration to other federal employees. This was something that existed a couple of years on either side of 2010, when MySpace was on its way out, Facebook and Twitter were just two among many vying for supremacy, and everyone thought GeoCities was quaint, ancient history.

    The people taking the class were a cross-section of highly technical early adopters (some of whom were old enough to know COBOL), linguists, various kinds of math and engineering people, and of all imaginable ages and backgrounds who shared one universal characteristic: they were not allowed to access their phones or the internet during the workday. So, they weren’t afraid of technology or new ideas, but they were not part of the rise of smartphones the way the rest of the population was.

    When I got to the section of the lecture on Blogs and “microblogging” apps, I always got the same question. They would hear about these apps where you could post your thoughts for millions of strangers to see, and they would ask me, “Why? Why would anyone think anybody else would care?”

    In all the years I was a Twitter user, I never had an answer for that question. The closest I have come to an answer struck me while doing family history research.

    Westmoreland, Kansas, 29 December 1892 – Westmoreland Recorder:

    A 19th Century microblog

    The Facts Will Document Their Feelings

    The first time I found a snippet like this, I didn’t know what to do with it.

    Is it… proof of anything? Yes. Is it evidence? Absolutely. Evidence of what, exactly? How do I file it?

    In this case, it puts a son and his parents in the time and place they are supposed to be. That’s a fact that was already established by various records. But what makes this special is dead simple: “A good time was had.”

    You could, if you wanted to be a cynical spoilsport, ask, “Who cares? Why would anyone think anybody else would care?” It’s such a small, pointless expression of people enjoying a moment, but it means that my ancestors enjoyed their moments together. That’s not an insignificant thing, even though it is small.

    It isn’t much, but it’s something, and that does make it the perfect Tweet.

    The Busy-ness of Life

    I don’t know if you have noticed, but I have struggled to find hooks when I write about this generation of ancestors. There is an unavoidable pattern: they were born somewhere, their family moved during their childhood, and they led unremarkable lives in a growing American Midwest.

    But they weren’t “unremarkable” in the sense that “they didn’t deserve to be remarked upon” – they simply weren’t dramatic or tragic. The things they did were part of the background of history, not the sorts of things that

    That’s not to say they didn’t suffer tragedies or endure their share of drama. It’s just that they happened to live during a time when disease was less prevalent than it had been a generation or two before, due to better sanitation, and there was a little bit more leisure time, due to various inventions and economic advances. A lot of them, like Abe Witter, lived between the time of the Civil War and the First World War without directly participating in either one.

    The things that made life hard tended to hit everyone, not just the Witter family. Abe and Nancy lost their first child, a girl named Myrtle, in infancy; but that was something that still happened often enough to be unremarkable, and the rest of their children were healthy and grew up to have families of their own.

    Abe was a farmer, which meant constant work and chores for everyone; but this was the end of an era when nearly everyone farmed, or at least grew some of their own food, and everybody had chores and work to do. They didn’t think those things merited constant documentation, and the little things that made life enjoyable rarely put a family’s name in the papers.

    Rarely, but sometimes…

    Postcards and Postscripts

    At some point, I remember seeing postcards handed down by the Witter family.

    “The Witter Boys” were builders, and one postcard credited them with building a local church in Allen County, Kansas. Of course, I don’t remember which church, or even which generation of “Witter Boys” it was, although it was most likely Abe and his brother Joe.

    I do remember that the postcards seemed hard to categorize, like the little newspaper mentions. They often carried a paragraph or two in brief sentences sketching out the million different ways people can say, “There’s nothing much going on here, but I thought I’d tell you about it, anyway.” I only had a few of them, but I got the impression that the family wrote to each other like this any time they were unable to visit frequently.

    It’s hard to know how to save all of that or capture it in a story, but it’s still important to know that they were telling each other, “I’m here. I miss you. And things aren’t too bad right now.”

    That’s what Tweets are for.

  • A Fundamental Difference

    In his publicity tour to promote his documentary, The American Revolution, Ken Burns calls it “the most important event since the birth of Christ.” Since most of recorded history predates the birth of Christ by about 3,500 years, and since events like “development of agriculture” and “taming fire” happened long before recorded history, I’m inclined to let Burns have that one. But what exactly was the “event,” and what did it mean?

    Americans are known around the world for being proud of their “freedom” without being nearly as interested in understanding what they are “free” of, what life was like before the Revolution, and what, exactly, the American Revolution changed that hadn’t changed during the various Reformations that preceded it.

    As Americans celebrated the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, you may hear many of them repeat Burns’s claim, so I thought it might be worth exploring what the “event” was, and what was important about it.

    Who Owns What

    The Atlantic recently published “The Moral Foundation of America” by historian and professor Elaine Pagels, with the slug, “The idea that everyone has intrinsic rights to life and liberty was a radical break with millennia of human history. It’s worth preserving.” I think that is the fundamental difference between “before the American Revolution” and “after” that Burns and most Americans are thinking about when they talk about how important that event was. But I also think something deeper and more fundamental is going on, and it isn’t easy to identify unless you take an extremely long view of human history.

    Academically speaking, of course, there was never just ‘one way’ of doing things. But if you consider what we know about human societies and how they organized themselves over time, and if you choose to over-simplify those organizations, there is an almost universal tension between “people who stay in one place” and “people who do not stay in one place” throughout recorded history.

    According to the Wikipedia article on “History of agriculture“:

    The development of agriculture about 12,000 years ago changed the way humans lived. They switched from nomadic hunter-gatherer lifestyles to permanent settlements and farming.
    Wild grains were collected and eaten from at least 104,000 years ago.[2] However, domestication did not occur until much later. The earliest evidence of small-scale cultivation of edible grasses is from around 21,000 BC…

    I do not claim that there is a clearly defined boundary between people who settled down in one place to raise crops and people who continued to wander to find resources; rather, I claim that the tension between those two general practices drove the development of what modern humans think of as ownership of land and the accumulation of what we call “wealth”.

    Once human beings developed agriculture, the need to defend static crops or herds from invaders (including other humans, but also pests) and to expand trade markets became central to what defined a given society. How a society produced crops, defended its farms, and traded for other goods with its neighbors came to define the different cultures that we talk about today – and the development of different cultures was not unique to any particular group of people.

    The Entitlement Mindset

    If you have ever maintained a garden, you know how much work goes into it: building and preparing the ground, planting, weeding, tending, culling out unhealthy plants, scaring off birds and combating insects. And if you put in the work, you probably feel that you should benefit from the crop. That is what you are “entitled” to have as your reward for the effort. You made it; it is yours.

    But what if someone who did none of that work comes along and demands the crop? Are they entitled to it? What if they have weapons? Are they entitled to take the food you grew, just because they are armed? What if they are armed because they own the land, and allowed you to do the work in exchange for protecting you from other, less deserving outsiders? Are they entitled to your crops, now?

    Over several millennia, that is a scenario that played out thousands of times, evolving over generations and across continents. Who owned the land started out as a question of who had the most power, and as that power accumulated with certain families, it changed. If you read that Pagels article, you can see where the dynamics of power stood in ancient Babylon:

    The anonymous Babylonian scribes who wrote the legal code of Hammurabi some 4,000 years ago seem to have regarded human value as a quality that the king could grant to certain people and deny to others. This code assigned privileges, and what we call “rights,” according to a strictly hierarchical view of social power.

    The archaeologists who discovered Hammurabi’s code must have been surprised, at first, to see that it offered certain protections from mutilation, torture, and execution. But it became clear that these were dependent on one’s social rank. The king—who authorized the code—assigned punishments based on the social status of the offender and the victim.

    These social ranks have taken different forms and been described in different ways, but it’s not hard to see how easily power and wealth were drawn up from the people doing the labor for the benefit of those at the “top” wielding the power. And those at the top needed to justify why they deserved to be at the top, deciding who got to eat, who got mutilated, or who got rewarded.

    Divine Rights

    In England, in the 1600s and 1700s, the King owned all of the land, and parceled it out to the landed gentry. These gentlemen would take their income from the people working the land, and they owed their power and a portion of the wealth they held to the King. Their tenants owned nothing and owed everything.

    The North American colonies were not intended to be an experiment in overthrowing that order. In fact, most of the people who came from Europe intended to make kings of themselves, carving territory out of the “untamed wilderness,” and making their fortune and their name.

    (Do I need to back that claim up, or is this an audience of genealogists who know exactly what their ancestors wanted?)

    Of course, there were already people here, living in that “untamed wilderness.” They had tamed it for their purposes quite nicely, actually, and if their populations hadn’t been rapidly depleted by the diseases coming from Europe, they might have been more successful in their attempt to resist the incoming waves of settlers.

    My personal theory is that over the two hundred years of colonial development, Europeans in North America absorbed quite a lot of ideas from their indigenous neighbors. I suspect the reason the American Revolution that led to the grand experiment of a democratically elected government owes as much to the ideas of individual liberty learned from the various Native tribes as it does to the Enlightenment philosophers we usually credit.

    After all, democracy is not a “top-down” sort of concept; by its nature, it has to flow from the bottom-up… and most of those on the “bottom” had little time for intellectual pursuits. But they would have been highly motivated to understand their neighbors, and those who were most successful at doing that would have survived to impress their understanding on their children.

    No More Kings

    In case you weren’t aware, the idea of abandoning monarchy and primogeniture was not universally accepted, even by the Founders. If you don’t believe me, you should go read Pauline Maier’s excellent “Ratification: The People Debate the Constitution, 1787-1788,” which captures the arguments made for and against the Constitution in debates, pamphlets, and newspapers.

    It is astounding how many people living in the America of the late 1780s considered our new form of government to be a violation of their faith, an atheist nightmare, and a doomed and dangerous abandonment of “our way of life.” Many of their intellectual descendants still want us to go back to that old way, but these days, they claim to be defending the Constitution as “our way of life,” even as they seek to concentrate power in the hands of wealthy landowners and deprive citizens of their right to vote.

    But for now, we still have a say in how we are governed, and after the last two years, I hope it is clear who wishes to behave like a king, doling out favors and deciding on a whim who lives, who gets rewarded, and whose rights are stripped away. I hope I don’t need to hammer the point home.

    And I hope you’ll help keep this experiment going on Election Day.

    Go Vote, Cousins!

  • Ahnentafel #51: Ida Slight (1863-1949)

    Ida Slight was the daughter of John Slight (1834–1879) and Frauke Margrette Sweeden (1824–1923), born on 24 Jul 1863 in Ackley, Hardin County, Iowa. She was a first-generation American born to parents who came to the United States from Lower Saxony, which is now a state in Germany.

    The Three Slight Sisters

    Ida was the middle child, one of three daughters born between 1862 (Anna) and 1866 (Hilke). Ida was named after her maternal grandmother, sort of. Frauke’s parents brought her and her siblings to the States in about 1855, and in the old country, her mother’s name was “Itje” which morphed into the more English-friendly “Ida” once the family settled in Iowa.

    The sisters grew up in Etna Township, Hardin County, Iowa, several miles south of Ackley. They almost certainly attended one of the nine schools mentioned in this 1911 article:

    In Etna township the first school was taught in the summer of 1855 by Martha George, in a building erected in the previous winter, of hewed logs, the work being accomplished by the neighbors interested. The size of this rude affair was eighteen by twenty-two feet and it stood on the southwest quarter of the northwest quarter of section 34, on land owned by Ichabod Lathrop. The attendance at this first term of school was twenty-one. By 1882 there were nine school buildings within the township and much interest taken in educational matters. (IAGenWeb, “Hardin County, Iowa Township Schools (1911)“)

    Younger sister Hilke was the first to wed; she married Heike Muller on March 28, 1885, in Grundy County, Iowa. The following year, 1886, Anna married John Brinkman, and Ida married Bernard Blom.

    Different Kinds of German Immigrants

    German-speaking people have been coming to North America since the earliest colonial settlements, and first arrived in the British colonies in significant numbers in the 1670s. France transported thousands of German people to the Orleans Territory in present-day Louisiana between 1718 and 1750. Benjamin Franklin famously complained about the prevalence of German-language signs and newspapers in Pennsylvania, worrying that his German neighbors were unwilling to assimilate and might supplant the English-speaking population of his new country.

    Some bad ideas about immigrants never seem to go away, despite centuries of evidence demonstrating their fallaciousness.

    Over 200 years, from the 1670s to the 1850s, different groups of German-speaking people came from Europe for different reasons. Those reasons were often related to religious strife in the Old Country, but as the anti-monarchy sentiments of the American and French Revolutions disrupted the old order, that religious strife often became political and violent.

    Arriving in America after the Civil War proved to be good timing for many of these groups, including the Slight family. The railroads (subsidized by government spending, and fueling outrageous wealth inequality, of course) generated an upward economic growth trend that made it easier for these hard-working farmers to try new techniques and to get the fruits of their labor to an increasingly nationwide and global market.

    Brinkmans, Mullers, and Bloms (Oh, My!)

    After they married, the sisters no longer lived in the same household, but their families lived close to each other. John and Anna Brinkman raised their nine children in Wright County, just north and west of Hardin County, while Barney and Ida Blom raised their five daughters in Ackley; Hilke and Heitle Muller raised their nine children in Grundy County, just east of Hardin.

    Of these 23 cousins, only one died young, as far as I can tell. Ida and Barney’s daughter Carrie was born and died in 1893. Otherwise, all of them appear to have grown and had families of their own, except for Flora Brinkman (born November 22, 1893), who died in 1913 during a measles outbreak. Apparently, she contracted the disease after caring for others in her family who had contracted it.

    After Barney

    Barney Blom died in 1917, when his youngest child, Edythe, was 17 years old. He had lived to see his older daughters married, and Edythe married in 1919. This left Ida more or less on her own. She supported herself for several years working as a housekeeper, but remained a widow until her death.

    Ida died at the home of her daughter, Mary McCullough, in Council Bluffs, Iowa, on January 20, 1949.

  • A Possible Next Step

    A wise friend gave me counsel a few years ago when we talked about my future retirement.

    I’m turning “Ol’ 55” next spring, and while I still enjoy doing… whatever it is that I am doing… I have been doing it since the mid-1990s, more or less. If my math is correct, the month I turn 55 will also be my 30th anniversary in federal service.1

    Randy’s advice was this, paraphrased: Figure out the two things you love doing most. Whatever the second favorite thing is, do that to earn a living. Doing the thing you love most for money will ruin it for you, and you need to keep doing that for the rest of your life.

    For me, the calculus came down to choosing between music and genealogy, but to be honest, I don’t like the idea of ruining either one.

    Monotonized Monetization

    An outside observer might tell you I have not been effectively monetizing my genealogy work.

    When I left Substack in 2025, I only had two paid subscribers. And in the decade or so that I have had books for sale on Lulu and Amazon, I have never sold more than a handful in a given month. (Did you know I have books for sale? That link is probably the second time I’ve mentioned them this year! Master Monetizer!)

    I could probably work on improving my marketing and SEO strategies, and generate content aimed at driving clicks and ad traffic… but that’s not who I am, or what I’m trying to accomplish. This blog and the projects I’ve done are meant to serve as a platform for the numerous cousins who will come behind me, seeking to learn where our common ancestors came from and what they were like. I don’t want to Enshittify my work for the sake of earning what I need to do the work.

    Still, Money is unavoidable because it is important to what I do in two ways:

    • 1. It costs money to access the resources I need.
    • 2. Supporting myself & my family takes time I would otherwise spend making use of those resources.

    If I had more time to spend, there are several large projects I would love to tackle. But that time requires money.

    Thus, the first half of the problem.

    Playing Well With Others

    The other half of the problem is “other people.”

    That doesn’t mean that I think other people are the problem; it means that the projects I have in mind are the types of projects that require a group effort. My Callin Family History ran to 800 pages, and took me seven years to compile and edit. I did all the work myself, so I can claim a minor triumph at getting it done, but I also have to own the flaws.

    Lesson: if I do another book project, I need to hire an editor.

    And I have several ideas for book projects.

    I’ve already talked about trying to update the Berlin Family History (or, at least, the volume that my family appears in). I’ve also been looking at other branches of my family that might not already have a published history. The Tuttles or the Clarks would be an interesting focus on my mother’s side; the Witters and Huffs would make a large study on my father’s side.

    Then there are all of those maddening local histories from the late 1880s and 1890s that are in the public domain. Technically, you can go buy a copy of the J.H. Beers Commemorative Historical and Biographical Record of Wood County, Ohio on Alibris or AbeBooks… but you are going to get a printout of the PDF from the Internet Archive bound by whatever print-on-demand service is available in Bangladesh.

    I have the ability to take those PDFs, clean the images, run OCR on the files, and adjust fonts and images. But hiring a copy editor would cost a minimum of $2.50 per page, and these books run into the 900 to 1,200 page range.

    No matter what projects I choose, I need to assemble a team to get the best results, and to make it worth the time and effort.

    The Pledge, The Turn…

    The idea I keep circling back to is to create an educational non-profit. While I don’t like the idea of trying to make my work into a business, I quite like the idea of creating something that would benefit the community.

    If I did this, I would need at least two partners – the sites I have been reading suggest having a President, a Secretary, and a Treasurer – to form the initial non-profit organization. Once formed, we would need to establish some required language about our purpose that explains what we are trying to do and what makes it an educational non-profit instead of a commercial business.

    For that first part (what we are trying to do), our purpose would be to republish public domain texts and family histories and donate copies to libraries and genealogical societies. As a non-profit, we could crowdfund our projects to hire editors and to fund the donation of the books. We could also offer the books for sale, as long as they are priced “at cost” and the profits go to the non-profit/educational activities.

    While print-on-demand companies can be hit-or-miss, I’ve been using Lulu.com for my family history books, and I’ve been very happy with their quality. Their hardcover options are sturdy and make fine additions to the public library shelves.

    There are existing organizations doing similar things already, but not quite filling the niche I’m looking to fill. NEHGS and American Ancestors are probably the best-known genealogy publishers, but they focus on producing new historical works. I have not found an imprint that reproduces reputable, quality versions of public domain texts, yet. (Otherwise, my bookshelves would be full.)

    What I envision is building up a library of these texts in a format that is accessible to people and to libraries, and will support the preservation and distribution of books like these for the next generation.

    The Prestige

    If I can find a couple of partners with expertise that I lack – particularly in accounting – I think we might start small, building a workflow for finding and processing the texts, building out our crowdfunding platforms, and raising what we need to hire editors for the first couple of projects.

    But if this works out, and we can sustain the growth, I can see this non-profit publishing several volumes per year.

    What do you all think? Is this already being done by someone I just haven’t connected with? Or is there a need for the Mighty Acorns Foundation?

    1. Because America doesn’t value human beings unless they are employed, that’s not enough for me to pack it in and expect a pension. Depending on which option I choose, I can’t claim my full pension until I meet the Social Security age, which for me is (I think) 67. So, another 12 years. ↩︎

  • Ahnentafel #35: Alice Ava Hale (1865-1942)

    Alice Hale was born on 16 April 1865, as the Civil War was ending. Her parents were Thomas B Hale (1836-1914) and Elmyra Spitler (1843-1904).

    Alice was the first child of Thomas and Elmyra, but she had three older half-siblings from her father’s first marriage to Mary Bowman (1835-1862): Ella (1857), Rilla (1858), and Baker John Hale (1861).

    A Farmer’s Daughter

    Alice grew up on her father’s farm in Washington Township, Hancock County, Ohio. She and her sisters were probably responsible for baking bread, churning butter, and processing fresh vegetables from the family garden, canning and pickling them to store for the winter. Laundry would have been an all-day chore, taking up a lot of the family’s time: boiling water by hand, scrubbing clothes on washboards, and hanging everything out to dry. Thomas’s household had nine children and his wife, plus Mary Spitler, probably one of Elmyra’s nieces, which meant more work for everyone, but also more hands to do it.

    Three Short Years

    Alice may have known Allen Greenlee from school, or through the social circles of church and local events in Hancock County. Even if she didn’t, her father probably knew who Allen was; a prominent farmer like Thomas Hale would have been aware of a young teacher and Cass Township clerk. He probably even knew about Allen’s 1882 trip to the county court on a “charge of bastardy.”1

    I don’t have any documents or letters to tell me what their relationship was like. They might have been acquainted since childhood, or introduced sometime in 1883. Alice may have been blissfully unaware of Allen’s legal troubles, but if Alice knew or found out about Allen’s relationship with a girl from the next township over, things may have gotten difficult between them.

    However tense the relationship might have been, Alice and Allen were married in August 1884, and soon had a baby daughter, Bertha May Greenlee.

    Alice and Allen were married for, at most, three years. We don’t know exactly when he died in 1887; only that he was buried in Bechtel Cemetery. We don’t know the cause of his death. We only have those few newspaper items that tell us anything about him or his life. They tell us he was ill in the fall of 1885, and moved his family in with his father-in-law while he recuperated. They tell us that he paid the tax on businesses that sold liquor in December 1886. They tell us he ran for office as a Democrat.

    These are small details that might mean nothing. Being a Democrat whose parents were divorced, a man who sold alcohol, and who may have had a child out of wedlock, living with a disapproving (Republican) father-in-law, who likely had strong opinions about the Union cause and temperance – all of these details might also mean those three years were contentious and difficult for Alice.

    But in the end, we just don’t know.

    A Second Life

    Typically, when a spouse died in that era, my ancestors remarried after about two years. Alice and Bertha probably went back to live with her father after Allen’s death, and on November 28, 1889, she married George McClelland Cramer (1861-1937).

    George (listed on the 1870 and 1880 censuses by his middle name, McClellan) was the son of Adam and Christina (Klinger) Cramer. He was born on October 23, 1861, and grew up in the Seneca County section of Fostoria, Ohio, where his father was a grocer and a postmaster.

    George was 28 when he married Alice and adopted Bertha. He was a brick mason and bricklayer – steady work, as paving bricks invented in the late 1880s became an important part of the growing road infrastructure in American cities. He continued in that business his entire adult life, retiring during the 1930s.

    George, Alice, and Bertha added another baby to the family in 1894, when Bertha’s half-sister, Mamie, was born. Despite being nine years apart in age, the two were very close. Mamie became a school teacher when she grew up. She was still living at home with her parents in 1920, when Bertha’s daughter, Yvonne, came to live with them.

    Mamie married Harlan Richard in 1922. Harlan was a machinist, and while he and Mamie never had children of their own, they spent a lot of time around their niece and nephews. In 1959, they retired to Florida, where Bertha and John Callin were living.

    Alice and George

    Once again, I find myself with a “happy ever after” sort of ending. We all know life isn’t a fairy tale, but for this generation of American Midwesterners, a steady income, good health, and a stable community were about as good as it got. George and Alice Cramer enjoyed their good health and relative prosperity in Fostoria and Findlay, where my Grandpa Bob Callin was born in 1920.

    Alice (seated, in the black dress) surrounded by family, probably around 1930.

    Unfortunately for me, their obituaries are not available online yet. I know that George Cramer died in 1937, and Alice followed a few years later in 1942. By then, her daughter and son-in-law and her three grandchildren, Bob, Yvonne, and Norman, were all living in Florida.

    But even without written evidence, the simple, fond fact of their presence permeated the lives of their family. I know from fleeting references in letters and the few recollections Grandpa shared that George and Alice were surrounded by people who loved them and whom they loved.

    So “happily ever after”? I’ll take it.

    1. We talked about what that meant in Allen’s Ahnentafel post. ↩︎
  • When They Had A Choice

    I haven’t had a lot of time to read all of the great things being posted in the genealogy and genealogy-adjacent history community, but I ran across a Substack post by Renee Stonebraker that gave me a new way to think about an old story.

    The 1911 Callin Family History and the 1990 Callen Chronicles each relate stories about a girl (or a pair of girls) from a family of colonial settlers in Pennsylvania, and how they were taken from their homes during a raid by Native Americans. Stonebraker wrote a June 16, 2026 essay comparing the Native American and Puritan/Colonial societies that lived side by side in the 1600s and 1700s, and challenging assumptions that people like me have made about those who were taken. Stonebraker shares several examples of these types of abduction stories in which the women who were taken did not wish to return to the Puritan societies they came from, preferring to remain with their “captors,” and explains why. (The saucy title is only part of the history!)

    When I have written about this particular pair of stories in the past, I focused on how little factual, confirmable detail we have, and how that plays into our habit of family history myth-making:

    As we learn more about our collective family history, we inevitably learn more about the mythology America’s European colonizers built around their experiences. And it is important to keep in mind what mythology means, because “myths” are not simply “true or false.” When they are the stories we tell about ourselves, they can incorporate facts, capture elements of our self-image and of our aspirations, and they can shape the way we interpret which parts of the stories are factual.

    Here’s a quick refresher:

    A Callin Family Myth

    The Callin Family History and The Callen Chronicles include what appear to be different versions of the same story.

    Here’s George Callin’s version, which he probably learned from his father, William, a grandson of James “1st” Callin. It is worth noting that George never met William’s father, John, and William never met John’s father, James:

    Record of Polly, Daughter of James 1st.
    Born about 1782. Grew to womanhood in her Pennsylvania home. Was captured by the Indians, and started for the Indian country. Her father James 1st gathered some neighbors and militia and followed the trail, they were guided by bits of clothing Polly had from time to time stuck on bushes. After several days pursuit, the Indians with their captive were overtaken. In the skirmish that followed Polly attempted to escape by running. An Indian fired at her just as she fell over a log and he supposing her killed did not further molest her, there her father found her after the fight, and the men made a litter and carried her home.
    She was shot through the knee, and for the want of proper surgical attendance, became a cripple for life. She never married, lived to be middleaged, and noted for the exemplary life she lived. The date of her death is unknown but somewhere about 1825.

    A Callen Family Legend

    The Callen Chronicles contains what might be another version of the same story (pages 17 & 19):

    It may be about this same time [the spring and summer of 1778, when Patrick Callen was enlisted with Capt. John McCleland’s company escorting provisions to Fort Hand in Westmoreland county] that the story has been told about Patrick’s and Sarah’s identical twin daughters, their names uncertain. (35D) “During the Revolutionary War when there was much Indian activity in Westmoreland Co., the two little girls were kidnapped in an Indian raid when Patrick was away from home. The little girls were about five or six at the time, and both were taken. About 10 or 12 years later (after the Revolutionary War was over) a fur trader went into a remote Indian village, in far western Pennsylvania or Ohio, to trade with the Indians. While he was in the village he saw two young white women, about 18 years old, living with the tribe. One was the wife of a young indian brave and had a tiny baby; the other was unattached, but under the “protection” of a family in the tribe. During his visit he had no opportunity to talk with either of the women; however, after he had traded with the indians and left the village, he found one of the young women under the supplies in his canoe. She told him that she wanted to return to her white family; she said that she had talked with her sister before leaving and that her sister had wanted to remain behind with her indian family.”  She was returned to Patrick and Sarah Callen – apparently just a short time before they moved to Armstrong Co. The story continued, “the returned daughter had not been injured or mistreated, the family that had taken her in in the tribe had treated her as a daughter. Though she never regretted returning to her natural family, she was often restless.  She was a private person, enjoying her time alone and in the woods, and she was described by her nephew, Watson, as ‘special and different’.  She had a way with wild animals that no one, not even her family understood.  She was slender, tall, and very blonde but she spent every day in the sun and the wind and she was as brown as an indian.  Watson said that his grandparents just let her be herself, and did not attempt to change her, but cherished her for who she was.”

    Determining which parts of these twin stories are “true” is challenging. The account in The Callen Chronicles contains more details, including a mention of the relationship between Margaret (the twin who was recovered) and Patrick Callen’s grandson, Watson. It is also a less dramatic story, told in a way that sounds more factual, although neither story has any facts that are likely to be verifiable by research. My hunch is that the Callen Chronicles’ version of the story is probably closer to “true” and that the Callin Family History version told about “Polly Callin” was altered and adapted as George’s grandfather and great-uncle retold the story to their children in Ohio.

    The nephew, Watson, mentioned at the end was a son of Hugh Callen, who founded Callensburg, PA, in 1825. It’s hard to know which of the known sisters of Hugh might have been carried off, or if the Chronicles simply didn’t include them. Hugh had a sister named Mary who was known as “Polly” (a common nickname for Mary). This Polly married a James Galbraith in 1815 and died in Kentucky in 1839, though, so she is not a serious contender for lead in this story, but it could be that the Ohio Callins remembered her name when they told their version.

    Making Her Point For Her

    Stonebraker tells us her thesis early on:

    Colonial America in the 1600s and 1700s had two systems running side by side. Puritan society, where sex was a procreative duty and a woman’s satisfaction did not register as a category worth discussing. And a number of Native American societies, where female sexual autonomy was an accepted, parent-sanctioned norm, alongside legal autonomy, property rights, and the ability to leave a bad marriage without asking anyone’s permission.

    Colonial women got to make that comparison, and a significant number of them chose Native life over their own. Not once. Repeatedly, across decades, across colonies, with women being recaptured and escaping again. They were telling Puritan society something, as clearly as a person can tell you something without ever publishing a word. Give us autonomy. Give us a say in our own pleasure, our own property, our own marriages, and we will stay.

    The reaction of the Puritan men is a shining example of how religious white males handle everything: poorly.

    Some obvious elements of the Callen Chronicles’ story resonate here (my emphasis, added):

    While [the trader] was in the village he saw two young white women, about 18 years old, living with the tribe. One was the wife of a young indian brave and had a tiny baby; the other was unattached, but under the “protection” of a family in the tribe. …after he had traded with the indians and left the village, he found one of the young women under the supplies in his canoe. She told him that she wanted to return to her white family; she said that she had talked with her sister before leaving and that her sister had wanted to remain behind with her indian family.” …”the returned daughter had not been injured or mistreated, the family that had taken her in in the tribe had treated her as a daughter. Though she never regretted returning to her natural family, she was often restless.

    If my theory about the two stories is correct, you can see how they evolved over years of retelling. Not only does the Chronicles version provide an example of a woman choosing life with the tribe over life with her family to add to Stonebraker’s, but the way the story changed demonstrates how the Callin men chose to rewrite the narrative.

    Their version omits the nuance of one sister choosing her Native American family and the other remaining single and “restless” for the rest of her life. Instead, Polly is rescued – the “damsel in distress” trope – and shot in the leg, which is used to explain why she remained single in a way that did not suggest any sexual immorality took place.

    The Truth Myths Can Tell

    As I said, I don’t expect to ever learn “the truth” about what happened to “Polly” or “Margaret,” or ever get confirmation that the two stories are about the same event. But it is endlessly fascinating to learn about the times that my ancestors experienced and get a glimpse into how they thought about things.

    I only hope that some of my writing answers the questions my descendants might have some day. More likely, they will be just as confused about what is true as I am!

    Good hunting, cousins! (And go give Renee Stonebraker a read!)

  • Ahnentafel #50: Bernard Blom (1861-1917)

    Bernard Blom was born on 30 June 1861 in Angerlo, in the Netherlands. His parents, Bernard Blom (1829-1912) and Maria Heijting (1832-1916), emigrated to America with their family in the 1870s and settled in Hardin County, Iowa.

    If you’d like to see the map of Angerlo, I included it when I wrote a brief overview of the family in Family Reunion: Blom. (And I’ll offer the Wikipedia article on the Netherlands, aka Holland, in case anyone is unfamiliar with the connection between those names and the people from there, who are referred to as Dutch.)

    Going Dutch

    All immigrants to America had to deal with stereotypes and some degree of mistreatment when they arrived in the States, but the Dutch immigrants endured less nativist hostility than other 19th-century immigrant groups. They enjoyed reputations for agricultural expertise and an intense work ethic, but also received gentle ridicule for their financial conservatism and religious insularity. You’ve probably used the phrase “going Dutch,” or “Dutch treat,” in reference to going on a date where each party pays their own way, even if you’ve never met anyone of Dutch origin.

    This is the power of American stereotypes. Even “good” ones.

    Still, Bernard and Maria brought their family to America in about 1872. Once they settled in Ackley, Hardin County, Iowa, Bernard supported them by working as a cabinetmaker. Together they raised eight children who survived to adulthood. They had twelve altogether.

    A Better Life

    Barney Blom arrived in America at about 10 years of age, the third eldest of the Blom children. His two older brothers were Dirk (1858) and John Benjamin (1859), and Barney was followed by Gerrit (1862), George (1864), and Antonie (1864), then by three sisters: Mary (1865), Anna Gertrude (1866), and Carrie (1868). Aleida Blom was born on 21 August 1871 in Angerlo, but I don’t believe she, Anna Gertrude, Gerrit, or Antonie survived to make the trip to America.

    While the United States was embroiled in the Civil War in the 1860s, the Kingdom of the Netherlands experienced a constitutional showdown between the Crown and the Parliament, economic aftershocks from the abolition of slavery, and a slow, painful transition toward a modern industrial economy. Once the War ended between the States, and the railroads began to drive our own industrialization, the U.S. seemed like a much more stable and safer bet than the European continent. The Bloms were part of a large influx of immigrants, bringing their eagerness to build a better life to Iowa.

    After settling here, Bernard and Maria had two more sons: William Arthur (1874) and Alexander (1878). The older boys stayed at home for a while, either working in carpentry and cabinetmaking with their father or as farmers. In 1883, Dirk married and started his own family, and carried on in the business of cabinetmaking. John Benjamin married the following year and took up farming; and in 1886, Barney took a wife.

    Barney’s Brief Legacy

    Barney married Ida Slight, and they had five daughters. Four of them survived childhood, including the eldest, Mary Elora Blom.

    After he married and started his family, it becomes all too easy to try to characterize the next thirty years as some kind of Midwestern, turn-of-the-century “happy ever after.” Losing a child in 1893 was a tragedy, but there were no other tragedies severe enough to put his name in the newspapers. It appears that he made a good living, raised his four daughters, and stayed close to his brothers and sisters.

    Barney’s life went along until March 1916, when his widowed mother, Maria, died in a fire that consumed her house. His brother George was grief-stricken by the loss and took his own life in May 1916 because, according to the note he left behind, he couldn’t stand being confronted by the charred reminder of her ruined house every morning when he woke up.

    Barney died a year later, in May 1917, when the limb from a tree he was trimming struck him in the abdomen. This is how the Ackley World Journal described the event:

    While trimming a tree on Fred Trainer’s lawn, on Saturday, May 12, Mr. Blom was in the act of shifting his position, when the limb he was sawing broke down, and, coming in contact with a dead branch near, the limb turned and struck him in the abdomen. He sank into the crotch of the two remaining limbs of the tree, stunned by the force of the blow. Succeeding, a few minutes later, in climbing down the ladder, he finally reached home and Dr. Miller was called to give medical assistance. The case was deemed so serious that the patient was, kept under the influence of anaesthetics to alleviate his suffering.
    The first yearning hope of the family for his speedy restoration to health and strength soon began to vanish, especially as the patient could take no nourishment, and Wednesday morning found him visibly declining. He was removed to the Miller hospital. A partial examination and operation revealed, however, that gangrene of the intestinal organs had set in and the faint hope that had centered about this last resort died away.
    After a day of intense suffering the shadoys [sic] of evening brought quiet and relief from pain, the sufferer sank peacefully to sleep at about nine o’clock and the spirit took its flight.
    Bernard Blom was the third son of Bernard Blom and Mary Heiting Blom, and was born at Gillerland, Holland, June 30, 1861. He died May 16, 1917, at the age of 55 years, 10 months and 16 days.

    Relating

    I think about Barney often, especially when I am doing the sort of job around the house that involves power tools and nature. Like, for example, trimming trees.

    Callin men tend to be accident prone, and I’ve written before about the mishaps that me, my dad, and my Grandpa Bob have suffered over the years. Learning about Barney Blom’s fate resonated with me, and the specter of all of these well-meaning, but often hapless, men makes me take extra precautions when I’m doing anything that could be dangerous.

    So far, I’ve been fortunate. But it’s always worth remembering that fortune can hold out for a lifetime before that one branch snaps the wrong way!

    Be careful out there, cousins!

  • Callan Name Study Update: Data, Data, Data!

    Last month, I spelled out the troubles I was having collecting an initial pile of census data for the Callan Name Study. When dimple commented with the wise suggestion to ask the app developer community at WikiTree, I said: “It will take me a few weeks to find time to look into that, so if anyone else wants to talk to them, feel free to point them at this post!”

    She took me up on that: G2G: This member needs some geek help

    And if you check out the selected answer from Arno, you will see that he offered a solution that was outside of my grasp, but gave him a couple of afternoons of fun. He ran his solution across the whole set of U.S. Census records from 1790-1950 and the two Irish Censuses (1901 and 1911). I added the whole table to my Callan Name Study spreadsheet.

    Number Talk

    If you open that spreadsheet, you should see four tabs (or sheets) along the bottom:

    • Collaboration form (we’ll come back to that)
    • Callan ONS individuals – the “final product” we’re working toward
    • FamilySearch records – the data Arno collected for us
    • Louth c. 1910 – the data I manually collected from the 1901 and 1911 Ireland Census (probably going away now)

    The FamilySearch records tab contains 44,155 lines, each representing a record (with a link to that record on FamilySearch in the “Record URL” column). If the record was attached to a FamilySearch person profile, that link is in the “FS Person URL” column – there are 23,978 lines in that column! When I de-duplicated that list, I had 13,300 individual profiles!

    It took me several months to manually pull out the records from the Ireland Censuses, and I only collected 642 individuals. Arno’s technique found 3,040 records. Even if you assumed that everyone overlapped between 1901 and 1911 (and they definitely did NOT), that would be 1,520 individuals from those two census years collected in an afternoon!

    What Next?

    Now that I have this spreadsheet to work from, the goal is to take the collection of records and organize it. If I have to go through 45 thousand lines by myself, I will do that, but I will be asking for help from the WikiTree community.

    Many hands make light work.

    That means that I need to work through a few lines of the list and design an outline with some clear instructions. I don’t know what that will look like, but:

    • Each Record URL needs a FS Person URL (even if that means creating a new FS Person profile).
    • Each FS Person profile needs to be matched to someone in the Individuals tab.
    • Each person in the Individuals tab needs to be matched to a WikiTree profile (even if that means creating a new WT profile).
    • The people in the Individuals tab need to be organized into families (identified under the OCA, or “Oldest Common Ancestor”, we can connect them to).

    There are probably some solutions that will be better than doing these steps manually, but I haven’t figured them out yet. For now, I plan to press forward and start asking for help in earnest once I know what specifics to ask for. (It’s more fun for people to help if it’s easy to understand how they’re helping.)

    If you decide to dive in and start helping, you won’t have editor access to my spreadsheet, but you can add someone to the ONS sheet using this “Add a person” form.

    Thanks again to everyone who took a moment to help move this project forward! I’ll keep y’all posted!

  • Ahnentafel #34: Allen Marion Greenlee (1861-1887)

    Allen Greenlee was my first real genealogy challenge. No one living seemed to know anything about him – starting with his name! – and even the records I could find were parsimonious with the information they collected.

    Peering Over Brick Walls

    Grandpa Bob was the one who first showed me the Callin Family History, so when I had questions, he’s the one I asked. But when those questions came to the origins of his mother, Bertha Greenlee-Cramer, he didn’t have many answers.

    He knew that she had been adopted by her stepfather, George Cramer, when she was very little, but beyond that, he knew nothing about her biological father. Great-grandma Bertha died the year before I was born, so I couldn’t ask her; but even my dad and his sister, my aunt Vicki, had no recollection of ever discussing her birth father with her.

    I was so new to genealogy that I didn’t yet know the term “brick wall,” but that’s not the metaphor I would have reached for. This sensation of facts being just out of reach or out of sight felt more like a weather event, like a dust storm or a heavy fog, where you can tell that there is something out there, but your light can’t reach it to tell you what it is.

    I could see the place where my great-grandfather should be, and I knew the shape of the hole that he left there, but I didn’t know how to start answering those questions. I didn’t even know what questions I should have been asking!

    A.M., Ellen, and Eleanor

    For a long time, “I think his name was Greeley or Greenlea” was the only clue I had. Then I found a marriage record for Alice A. Hale and “A.M. Greenlee” in Hancock County, Ohio, dated 16 (granted) and 17 (return) August 1884.

    Ohio, U.S., County Marriage Records, 1774-1993; Film Number 001299133

    I knew Grandma Bertha’s birthdate was 5 December 1885, so the timing wasn’t a big surprise, but when you are relying on freely available census records for all of your research, it is an inconvenient mid-decade to get lost in. Only having his initials made it that much harder to know who to look for on the 1880 census. (And, as you may know, the 1890 Census was lost, so no joy there!)

    With some guesswork, I did find Allen Greenlee living with his grandmother, Eleanor Bollman, in Cass Township, Hancock County, Ohio, on the 1880 Census. His occupation was listed as farmer, and his father’s birthplace was Ireland, while his mother’s was Ohio. In 1870, I found them again: Eleanor (with her name transcribed as “Elesur”), and “Ellen Greenlee,” a male, 9 years of age. This time, a 31-year-old woman named Sarah C. Bollman was also listed. She would prove to be Allen’s mother, but it would take many years and a paid Ancestry subscription to find enough pieces of the puzzle to be sure.

    The Will and the Newspapers

    When I decided to revise the Callin Family History in 2015 and paid for the full Ancestry subscription to help me do it, I found Sarah’s 1875 will. In it, she named her son, Allen Marion Greenlee, and left him all of her property and named Ezra Karn his legal guardian. This confirmed many guesses I had made, based on what I could see in the census.

    About that same time, Newspapers.com began digitizing The Weekly Jeffersonian, and as I found small mentions of Allen Greenlee in their pages over the years, a figure began to emerge from the fog.

    In April of 1882, Allen Greenlee reported that 11 of his sheep were killed by dogs, and, in a later item, that he and Elizabeth McComb exchanged property. Elizabeth McComb’s maiden name turns out to have been Bollman, making her a sister of Allen’s mother.

    In 1882, he turned 21 and came into his inheritance. He exchanged land with his aunt, raised sheep on what was now his land, and got a teaching certificate. In 1883, he was elected clerk of Cass Township (as a Democrat!) and served as umpire for Wineland and Marion baseball clubs in 1884.

    As we saw from his marriage certificate, he married Alice in 1884, and in December 1885, they had Bertha. But in September 1885, the papers mentioned on the 10th that Allen suffered from typhus, and reported he was “up and round again, yet very feeble” a couple of weeks later. In October he and Alice moved into her father’s house.

    For a long time, I assumed he died because of that typhus infection, but in December 1886, the paper named him as one of the men paying the “Dow Law tax,” which was a tax on businesses that sold liquor. Since that news placed him in Arcadia, it suggests he and Alice moved out of her father’s house and started a business that involved selling alcohol. That suggests that he recovered from the typhus, at least.

    And sometime during 1887, he died and was buried in Bechtel Cemetery, with no mention in the papers and no obituary. But there is one more twist in Allen’s story, and it happened before he married Alice Hale.

    Ohio Progressivism

    In June of 1882, a few months before Allen’s 21st birthday, the paper reported what sounded like a scandal to me:1

    “Allen Greenlee, a young school teacher residing north of this city, was arrested on Tuesday and brought before Justice Beardsley, on a charge of bastardy preferred by Miss Dora Nickey, a lass aged seventeen years. Greenlee was bound over to court in the sum of $500.”

    While that language sounds punitive, it was apparently a legal mechanism for a woman to claim financial support and legally name a father without having to marry him. Based on what I was able to learn online, it seems from the language of being “bound over…in the sum of $500” that the court found Allen responsible, but there was no follow-on report to say either way.

    One unanswered question raised by this: was Dora one of Allen’s students? They both grew up in Cass Township, so they may have gone to school together there as students or otherwise been childhood sweethearts, even being four years apart in age. Dora was 7 years past Ohio’s age of consent, so this would not have been considered statutory rape as it would be today.

    We don’t know if he was her teacher, but in 1882, there was no law prohibiting student-teacher relationships. That law passed on 22 April 1886, four years after Allen was sued by Dora. And judging by the fact that he was elected to local office and held positions of trust after this, it seems the community considered this matter settled after the court ruled.

    I found no evidence of a child in Dora’s family that was born in 1882, so it seems most likely that she gave the baby up for adoption. That suggests I might have a whole set of cousins descended from Allen who have no idea where they came from. For now, I don’t have any clues to go on, but I will keep an eye out for leads to help find them.

    Perhaps one day, I can help them peep over this brick wall, too.

    1. Newspapers.com, The Weekly Jeffersonian, Findlay, Ohio, 1 Jun 1882, Thu, Page 3, “Allen Greenlee, a young school teacher“. ↩︎